Yes, things have changed recently! I would say that without considering the portion of gamut not covered in chromaticity by the Epson SC-P900 (always represented in green), the two gamuts are really very similar. In particular, dropping the graphs in the real world, with the Epson SC-P900 I can push a bit on the chromaticity of blues and greens (great for seascapes and forests for example). The Epson does advertise lower power consumption whilst printing, at 75W compared to the Canon at 112W. The Epson in contrast produced skin tones that were flat and pale in comparison. On the other hand, the victory of the Canon iPF PRO-1000 on the warm tones that are so dear to landscape photographers for sunrises and sunsets (where its easy to find some high-saturated situations) is overwhelming. Both printers offer excellent image quality as would be expected for printers in this class. Not only does it deliver a higher optical density in the Blacks, which is an important attribute for the photography market but it also delivers crisper, clearer text and lines with more vibrant colours than the Epson. As we know, however, chromaticity is only a part of the color, so lets now consider luminance through three-dimensionality. It provides a simplified but powerful printing interface for their SureColor Series printers. On the contrary, this article focuses on one of the fundamental characteristics of a printer in my opinion, which is the ability of the printer/ink/paper combination to reproduce colors on a defined paper support. The Epson also does have smaller (but variable) ink drop sizes. Released (and purchased) in 2011 is a bit like an old Vespa: outdated, but still reliable. Museums, galleries and professional photographers of the highest caliber produce prints on both of these brands of printers. A couple of tips to help alleviate this problem is to use a compressed air blower (canned air) to blow dust out of the top feed tray. On certain areas of the chromaticity diagram, the Canon iPF PRO-1000 performs much better as we can better see from the Lab diagram on the right. Extended warranties have to be purchased within 11 months of the original printer purchase. Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF, as a product range, do not have to switch between black inks as there are two separate channels on the head to accommodate both Photo Black and Matte Black. Epson printers can only do this with a third party software. With desktop printers, the issue is caused by environmental dust and paper dust getting into the printer and coating the parts that grab and transport the paper, causing a misfeed. Both the Canon and Epson printers delivered image quality expected of machines targeting the Graphic Arts market. As someone rightly pointed out to me, you cant live just using matte papers! The Canon PRO-4000 is able to distinguish which black ink is required according to the paper settings when sending to print and will then only use the ink type required for the print. This feature allows users to replace ink cartridges while the machine itself is still actively printing and is not something that is available on the Epson device. This process does not take too long ? Im sure you know, I love to print. You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us. The current product range from each company are the Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF and Epson SureColor printers. If this obviously sounds bad to you, or if you simply send to the printer images associated with the sRGB profile, I suggest you first read some other article on this Blog about Color Management so you can fully enjoy what you will find between these lines. Difficult to represent it with some simple screenshots, but both where the Canon iPF PRO-1000 (always represented in red) is superior, and where the Epson SC-P900 is, the Gamut delta is really minimal. The replacement itself is pretty straightforward and not expensive. If youre not basically a Nerd, youll be bored reading this reviewat least you know it in advance , In order not to make this article just a Nerd treatise but something useful for those who are trivially interested in printing and maybe need to make a purchase, as usual, I will simplify and trivialize certain topics much more complex. The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes. Epson Weekend power consumption - 48 x 19W = 912WCanon weekend power consumption ? These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Specific tests were conducted to compare image quality, productivity, ink consumption, device feature sets, cleaning routines and more. It is important to note that Epson printers are designed to be turned off when not in use. the fact that the gamut of glossy and lustre cards are normally more comfortable than opaque ones) we are unlikely to face any problem. This however does not mean that you will never need to perform a nozzle check and head cleaning procedure, the frequency should be far less though. You can also use a paper towel or cloth saturated with rubbing alcohol and coat the little rubber foot in the printer that grabs the paper. You can then choose to update the firmware when the alert is posted on the LCD screen of the printer. The system can also act as a take up spool, rolling the paper emulsion in or out depending on how you set it up a great option for long panoramas. It would be really interesting to try these printers to understand the combination of gamut described above with the other peculiarities of each printer to evaluate them as a whole, but until then I think my trusty Canon PRO-1 will still grind a lot of paper! This can be done via the free software provided ? If we take for example my image of the fiery dawn that we analyzed earlier for the cotton paper (the one that the Epson SC-P900 could not cover), we see that on this paper there are no problems in chromaticity or luminance as it can be completely caged by the gamut of both printers. no more than a few minutes, but it does waste ink.
The bottom line is, each brand has its own quirks and idiosyncrasies.
Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF printers utilize a single, user replaceable, printhead (PF-10) and come with a 1 year warranty. The Epson SureColor printers now run automated, periodic nozzle check and head cleaning cycles to help minimize head clogging issues. Both brands of large format printers have several sizes of ink cartridges that can be mixed in the printer based on usage. Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF printers offer an optional Multi Function Roll System which allows you to load two rolls on to the printer at the same time and switch between them via Print Studio Pro or Professional Print & Layout software. As you can see overall, there is not much in terms of gains to be had in power consumption. Epson Printing ? If we want to notice a trend, the Epson SC-P900, always talking about the chromaticity covered by both printers, would seem more able to handle high luminance, while the Canon iPF PRO-1000 allows us to have deeper blacks. To replace a printhead on an Epson requires a service engineer callout and this, along with the cost of the replacement printhead can cost thousands of pounds. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. It may be that my beloved long exposures lend themselves well to cotton papers, but I will never tire of suggesting this paper to those who want to print. If you were to factor in weekend downtime, you can see that the Canon PRO-4000 has the advantage back. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Lets extend our dimensional world into the third dimension and so lets see how the two printers behave on this glossy paper also in terms of luminance. Freestyle never discloses, sells, or shares any of your information.
The PRO-2000 had the edge overall with brighter colours, more natural skin tones, sharper detailing and crisper text. As you know one of the prerequisites to print correctly is to profile our printer (and therefore the whole printer body + ink load) for the paper we want to use. Its a fabulous cotton paper because even though it belongs to the Rag family it has less texture, a very nice white point and a very high black point (Dmax), which is the Achilles heel of all cotton papers. As we can see, what jumps to the eye from the chromaticity diagram on the left is that the Epson SC-P900 (released in 2020) on this matte paper (and continuing the tests we can tend to generalize to most of the cotton papers) has a gamut very similar to the one of the Canon iPF PRO-1000 (released in 2016!). These cookies do not store any personal information. (For the record, there are very few other parameters that interest meamong these I would certainly consider maximum print size and ink type to name a few, and I would certainly not consider size, weight, noise, print speed, LCD display and other details that are irrelevant to me). This article is not supported or sponsored in any way by the two brands mentioned: they have not provided any material or support for its drafting. To prove what I was saying, if we take one of my images with very saturated colors on blue and green, I still have no problems with either printer because saturated blues and greens in nature never reach critical values. More often than not, it is not really a financially sound option to go ahead and replace the part and another printer purchase may be a more viable alternative. It allows you to export the cost per print job for ink and paper into a .CSV file, enabling you to easily calculate your cost per print.
Epson offer an X-Rite Spectrophotometer (SpectroProofer) as an optional extra to provide colour management control.
Usually glossy and lustre papers have a wider gamut than matte papers, and we can see this by comparing the gamut of a typical cotton paper with a typical glossy paper. The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This is the hard cold reality of inkjet printing and is why the manufacturers have the ever popular Nozzle Check & Head Cleaning feature built in to every printer. For this reason, I think it is essential to make some premises.
Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF 24 inch and wider printers have to bend so you can not feed stiff board-like material through them. Canon PPL is built around the concept of easily printing multiple images on a page. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. But how do the Epson SC-P900 and Canon iPF PRO-1000 perform in this new world with expanded boundaries? When you look at this in real terms however, all that glitters is not necessarily gold! Starting from the two-dimensional analysis for the chromaticity, honestly I think the result is anything but obvious. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. With the Epson, printing has to stop for the ink cartridges to be replaced, which does mean for more downtime. Up until recently the popular Epson Stylus Photo and SureColor range of Epson pigment-based printers needed to physically switch between Photo Black and Matte Black ink based on the type of media you are printing on. First, there is no doubt that both Canon and Epson produce excellent printers. Canons newer program called Professional Print & Layout printing program allows you to perform basic nesting and more advanced layout tasks than ever before. In the search for candidates, this time Im going up a level in the print size to bring me from my current maximum A3+ to A2, which for the segment of professional home photo printers we can say represents the new upper limit. This feature also records the data the printer used to print a file, allowing it to be recalled later and printed directly from the LCD screen of the printer, rather than sending the print job from a computer. Once again we remind you that printing a photo with an associated sRGB color space (in green) is like buying a Ferrari and then keep it in second gear because the gamut of a typical paper (in black) will always be higher, and therefore we are losing colors. When printing 50 page runs of three different test documents the Canon PRO-2000 performed better in terms of ink consumption, using significantly less ink in terms of net weight. Below are features and comparisons of each model to help you understand the functionality of each printer brand before making a final decision. canon plotter prograf ipf You can also access this information on a per job basis from the LCD screen of the printer itself. Click here to view or download the full data sheet, Copyright 2021 My Large Format Printer (MyLFP). We must say, however, that if we drop this in the real world, for what we have seen before (i.e. Hopefully this short guide, with a quick look at the main features should help you decide which printer will be best for your needs. All Canon and Epson Desktop type printers utilize only one size of ink cartridge. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Canon Europe commissioned a report to be produced by Buyers Lab to look at the relative strengths and weaknesses of the Canon imagePROGRAF PRO-2000 versus Epsons SureColor SC-P7000. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Canon printers come with a full set of usable ink. What does it mean? Certainly not by making a classic review, as it would be too much subject to the printing skills of the author and in any case based on a subjective feeling dictated by holding a printed sheet in the hands (Is it printed correctly? A replacement head on an Epson printer is under warranty for 90 days. I dont think theres an absolute winner, and anyway were talking about the two flagship printers from Canon and Epson for professional A2 home photo printing, so two incredible machines that both allow us to reach a home printing quality that we once could only dream of. Another significant time saving feature is that of the hot swap ink tanks with the Canon, which means you are able to swap an ink, even when the printer is active during a print job with seamless un-interruption. The jury is still out on archival permanence. Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF Pro-2100 comes with 160 ml of usable ink for all 12 cartridges and the Pro-4100/6100 printers come with 330ml of each ink. Canon printers also require less cleaning and will survive for longer periods of time of non-use. If the printer seems like it is drifting in color over time or you need to replace the printhead or other major service, you can simply zero out the current calibration and re-run the color calibration procedure using the exact same Canon Brand paper. 
The results are below and demonstrated that the Canon PRO-2000 outperformed the Epson P7000 in the majority of test categories.
These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. An absolutely subjective and understandable choice. We are here to help though. I use three of them, but the one that gives me the most satisfaction and that I use most often is the Hahnemhle Fine Art Pearl, a 285 gsm -cellulose with a very delicate texture and a very bright white point.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. (The iOS version will only be compatible with SureColor P700 & P900 printers.). 75W x 8 = 600W Epson Standby ? While testing from some independent companies show that Epson inks can be more resistant to fading vs. the new Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF printer inks, the reality is that the composition of the media you are printing on, as well as the environment in which you are storing or displaying your image, have much more to do with archival permanence than any other factors. To see this in an example, lets try again to graph a particularly saturated image. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Special Update: The newly introduced Epson SureColor P700 and P900 desktop printers will now feed Fine Art Matte papers from the top paper feed tray enabling you to use the correct Velvet Fine Art Media Type Setting. These doors have to be opened to replace the ink tanks, which means interrupting your print job. The Epson does offer a slightly larger colour gamut (9.3% larger gamut when printing on Semi-gloss photo paper at high quality) than the Canon when compared like for like and it was found the neural grey consistency was maintained well by both models too in the independent tests performed by Buyers Lab. alistair designsupply Copyright 2022 Francesco Gola | All Rights Reserved | PIVA: 02730980428. However the Canon has the lower power consumption whilst in standby mode at 1.8W compared to 19W of the Epson. Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF Pro-1000 and larger printers all come with a built-in feature on the printer itself allowing you to connect the printer via wi-fi to periodically ping Canons Firmware Server to look for available new updates. It requires an on-site service call from an authorized Epson Service Technician and can cost up to $2,500 on the SureColor 24, 44 and 60 inch printers. Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF printers come with a built in hard drive. 
Canon PRO Series imagePROGRAF printers also come with a FREE program called the Accounting Manager. To make the analysis more complete, we are going to analyze the profile both in Yxy coordinates (as it allows us to take advantage of the intuitiveness of the chromaticity diagram), and in Lab coordinates (to better evaluate the different shades of gamut). But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. Since in fact this article is an aloud thought made about whether or not to replace my printer, I choose to evaluate how the two printers behave on the two papers I most commonly use, which are: The first objection I try to intercept is the one related to the fact if it is not better to evaluate the printers on the papers produced by Canon and Epson themselves. Our Canon Gold Partnership Continues into 2021, Enhanced Printing At No Extra Cost - TM Series Software, Discontinuation of Canon PFI-101, 301 & & 701 Inks, Using the free layout tool for extra large prints, Two Worlds Collide | Ayla Golf Club | Chapter 2, CLICK HERE to view the full BLI Comparison Report for Canon PRO-4000 vs Epson SC-P9000. The Canon PRO-4000 and the Epson SC-P9000 are both printers aimed at the Graphics and Photographic Market places. Keep on running these cycles as necessary until the nozzle check pattern looks like it is free from clogs. This will reset the printer to the original standard. The media setting determines which ink you are using and the printer just prints the ink you want. Honestly, its unexpected since given the technical specifications of the new Epson with particular reference to the new UltraChrome Pro 10 inks and given that were talking about a machine 4 years newer, I was really expecting something more punchy.
The more you use your printer, the more use you will get out of it!