"1 #.).
" " !1"
1!" !1 *+ +00+ "" 0**000 ***,,,* 10+,,,* ! !
!11" "" " !10++ 000 +*+ 1!!! "
" #.)%((''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%$-#/**++++++++**********++++01! " 1
11" +,-$$%(&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&&((%$)/**++++++++++++++****+++ 01! " California has chosen to participate in the program, terming its medical benefits program "Medi-Cal."
01" "!1 ! "11
,)$$%(((%$).
1983) 700 F.2d 749.
!!! !111+****+01"
""
1
11! .$%(''''''&&(($.-/*++ 1! 1000
+*,/,/###*****+ 000 +++++++ 00000 +*****+ 00 /----, !" "+****,,/,+0 +/,+
!
/. "!!10+,)%&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&%)+!0*,#))$$%(((((%$/*! )%(&''''''''''''''''''&&&(()-*
0++ 0 !1 " !10 */,* 1 !1!
""" "11110 0
!1 *,#-. In September, he resumed his schooling and met his preaccident anticipated graduation date by taking a double course load.
*/##*+01110 ** "
*/)%.%((((((%(&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''(%)+" +*,,,,/,,,2-)$%(&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''(%%),+ "+*+++++++ +* !10 ++*,,,,,,/-.%%(&&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''&((. //**,#,+0 ++1 Edwards did not seek a state hearing; instead, she filed this action for injunctive relief, contending the state was obligated pursuant to 42 United States Code section 1396a(e)(1) to continue payment of Medi-Cal benefits for a period of four months following termination of AFDC benefits, and that in any event payment of benefits must continue until eligibility therefor is redetermined under the guidelines applying to the "medically needy" recipient category.
"0+0+*,2)$%(((''3''3''''''''''''''''''&&&&&&&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&($)-0 *##,**+++ 0*,*+ 1 """
0++01!" !0++1 !
01 1 ***+ 1!
" !!! +#,* " !!
"
" "*/.
"!000000""
"!+-..$(&((((((((&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%., 1 0 +*,/#-)$(%(&&'''3''''''''''''''''''&&&&&&&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%$.
,#-)%&'''''''&%$.11 +***********+ ++**,,,,,,,*+0
" 0
"1001! !11111! ""
!1!
**+ 0 +*,#+01 " !100 +*,/ 1! 0 ++ 00 " ""1100 0 "11
1+,###,* 0 *** 01!!10111!! """"" 10 0
10+,,
" !
"!*)$%&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%.#!"
+/,,,,*0
02
0+++++0 "
!1 *, 0"
"0 ,///,,****+10+**0! !111111! ""
10 ++++++**,#/,*+!
++ 1! """ ***+0"!! 0 !
!+/.
""!+,-.%((((%$))))-#/+1 " " !1111 +++ !++ 0!!
" ,#)((''''''''''''''''''''''&&(%%)/*!
!0+++*+ +*,+1"" +++ 1 ++*+ +1 *
"1 !+*
+/,+
0++ 1"10+*++ 1110*,#)%(''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&'&&(($))..-/* 01 """"10 +,#-. +*,,,,,* 000 +,. "10+++++,/#2,,+0! "
"" !"
!+ " +,.$(&3'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&&&&(((&&&&((%%$$$)..--/,++ 0 " "!00 "
!0+,2#/+ 0! /,2#,* " *+ 11110+*,2,+ 1! In March 1982, Edwards received a notice of action stating that her AFDC and Medi-Cal benefits would be discontinued effective April 1, 1982, due to expiration of her entitlement to the "30 and 1/3 disregard."
"0+0 "1!
!0 +*+
1
, !!!!!!!"
"+,2.$(&&&''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%%$.--*+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 00011! "
(((&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&(%)/+
"!0*/*+0001! 10++ 1 1"
/,,,,,#,* + "
*22/,*0!
1!"
"1" "!10+****++ +++ 01" +,,////,,,,,,,,,*+ 010 ++,,//,+01
!1 ++,,,,/,#2// ! 0 +*,/2-.
*,#/,* 001!!!
11 +**#-2/*"0 +++ ++ 0!"
Subchapter XIX of the Social Security Act established the Medicaid program to provide federal financial assistance to states choosing to reimburse needy persons for certain medical treatment costs. <>stream !10 +++++ 011111 0*/#,,,//,**+++ 000 ++**,,,,,,+ 1" " !11! This "30 and 1/3 disregard" was designed to encourage AFDC recipients to work by removing the disincentive of termination of benefits upon employment.
!
,$%$%$$)$$)..-
Because of the accident, plaintiff, a college student, was unable to take final examinations scheduled for three weeks after the accident.
""""" !0-%(&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&&(((((&&&&&&((%%%%$)$$..-,+ 0001!! 1+ +++ 00 *,/2#/ ! !00 +++++++++ 000000000001! " !+,.$&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&(%$).-#/01! "1 #))&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&&&&&&&&&&&&(%%.-,*+ 1!""" "
!0
"0 *,,,,+01110**!
"!-)%&&&'(%$),01 100
"!1+/###/+ +++*,//######/* !
11!" In California, OBRA resulted in the elimination of the "30 and 1/3 disregard" on April 1, 1982, to persons who had been receiving AFDC benefits on its effective date.
0+** !"!1!!
" 2.))..---..----..
1! & Inst. 1 0 +**,,,///,,*01" 0+/.
11!
" * "
"!00 0001!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 *,-$$$%$$))). !0 *+0" Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court in favor of defendant, entered July 9, 1982 in Chemung County, upon a verdict rendered at Trial Term (Smyk, J.). "0 *,,,,,,,,,* " +****+ 1111 +,,,,,/+0" !1"
!0#)$%&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&%%$)-2 !
))$%%%%(((((&&''''''''''''''''&(($-+
111
"0#-)))$%$$$$$$$$$$$$%%%%%((((%%%%$$$$$$$$%%%%%%%$.01 ""1+*** ++ '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&(.#! *,)-#/+1 1 * 1! 0++ 0 !1 * "
10 0!
"! "
0000145694 00000 n
" !" " 10+#-)$%&&&''''3'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&'&(%./*+01"!!!!!!!!!!!!! +,--%%((&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&(%$).---..
!00000"
0 " .%(&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&&(((%$$$$$)$%(((&&&'''''''(%%%%$$)))..#/,***,,,###. #//,,,,,//#22#,** 11-$((''''''''''''''&(%)-0
!
+/.$$%(&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''((((%).2+ In a previous opinion, we held the terminations proper. "" )%(&&&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%$.#/**++++ ++++****++++******+ 0! xref
""11110 +*,/#*0!
"!11!
!
""10
"1 "
++
0 +0" !1 + +++++
"""
!1 +*/#,+ 1
"!
0+
0000148317 00000 n """" !11100000 ++++++++++ ***********++++++ +++ 001!! " !1 "1 +,,///,,,,+0!" !111! " " !1 ,##.$%$.0 )%&'&&&&'''&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''(($-*1 "0+**+ 0 +*/#,**""" "!!!!!
'''''''''''&&%$)-,*
" **0 "11"""""'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&'&%$)#*
0++++++++**-.)).
"10 1!
1+,/#/1
"+-)$(&(&((%$--)))).#,,*+ 1+--%%&&&''&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&((&(%$))))$)))))).)))))))))))))./*!" *.)))).)$$%%(((((&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&((%.+!
+/--/*0 """0+*++ 1!!+,,*0!" +*,**+****+ "! ''''''''''''''''&(%$$.#/+ "
!
0+,#/*01 " 0 0
"!+#.$%&''''''''''''''''''''&&&&(%$)-2***++**++++++++++++ 0001"
/#-)$%(((&(&&&&&&&&&&&&%).,+" !1
1 +,#-. "!
100001! " .)$%%%)."""!! !11 #01 "
$$),,,/,,0!"! "1 +**+ 000 +!11000 *,.$$%%%%%%%%%%%%%(((&&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%-+ "!2)((''''''''''''''&&($., " !
" /#-))))))))..-#, !
)$$$$%(((&&&'&&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&%$-#,+ " !10+***** " +***++ 0 +,,,+" ++ 0!
0000005940 00000 n "*)%&''''''''''&''(%)20" ,,,*+0!!!
""!1+.$((&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&($$.#,+!""""
"
222/,,* 00++,###/ " *,,,+ 01" !0 01!!!!
,)(&&''''''''''''&&(%$)#,*+++++ + 001 "
*++ """" 1! " " 0++0! +" "0++0! " $%(((&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&((%$)-2,**++++++++++++++++++**+****+ 01!!"""
" 00 " "1!" "" !!1!"" 1396 et seq.)
""""!02.$%&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&&((%$)..---$%((&&&&''''''''''''''&&&(((%%%$$$$)))--.)))$$$%%(((&&&&&&'''&(%%(($)).-.. "1 ,2.$%%(&''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&&%)./+!"
""!0 +0!!!
!00+**,,,,,//,, 1!! !!!! ""
"!0 + 01 !
! "!!!!"
"+/--%%&(&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&(%$$)).--..
" ,#/* 1+**,#.%(('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&($.
!1 000000++++++++++++***+0+*,//,*1 " !001!"
" 0)$(''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&((%$)#///#/*+0 !+.$&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&((%$).--,*
!0 ++ 00+ )$%%%%%((((&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(()-# 1"
!1111 *//+01!! " " !" +* 1! """"
*,//,* !1! " 0 +0 ++" ! +/-$((&&&((%-#/*++ !"" +**+00 011! " !10*/##,0!!+,+1!
)$(&&'''&'3'&(%$.#1 !0*0"
+2//,/#/+1
+,-)(&&&%%%./01
"1 " 0 0" !1!"
0+*
0 1" "!10 +**,#-.$%&&'''''''''''''''''&&(%$-2,+" 1*/-$%(&&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''(((((((((%$)-#/+011*/-$(&&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&((%).#,+"10*,#-)%%%(''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''((($)-#, !" "!100
!1""!+*+* 0 ++22/,+1! ,#+01!0+*1
,.%(&&'''''''''''''''''&($., !0
(&''3'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&'''''&(%)/*" "! "
0 + +,,,,*++++ 01111!!! ,+ 1!
++0
! " "+,####/,+0!" '''''''''''''''''''''&(%$. ""0+*+00 *,,,,***+++ 000 +**,/,+01 " .$(&'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&&'''3''''''''''''''''&&((((((%%$$))..).--#/,*+ 01!!!!!
"0+,* 1 ,,,+! "1!
0000147593 00000 n )$$)..-)$%%((((&&&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&(%$#0"
"1+**+ 011!!"
0!
0 0
Prior to 1981, $30 plus one-third of an AFDC recipient's earnings were excluded from income for the purpose of determining eligibility for benefits under that program. .$%&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&%%$-+
!0 +***,.)%(&&&&&'&&&&&&&&''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''&((%. "11
!1 *2-.$%%(&&''&&&&&&&&(%(.01
!!